Intown Atlanta Neighborhoods Compared: A Local Agent's Eastside Guide
Trying to choose between intown Atlanta neighborhoods? I'm Alan Corey, and I lead the Alan Corey Team at Atlanta Brokers Collective. I've spent about 25 years in Atlanta and in real estate as an agent, property manager, builder, and flipper, and my team has ranked in the Top 1% of the Atlanta Association of Realtors every year since 2016 in both transaction volume and total sales.
I've also lived on the eastside for years: 10 years in Oakhurst, a few years in Virginia-Highland, and the past 4 years on the border of Candler Park and Druid Hills. Here's how I'd compare seven of Atlanta's best intown eastside neighborhoods.
The Short Answer
Candler Park: a big park, a walkable village, and one of the best Halloween streets in Atlanta in Page Ave
Druid Hills: large lots and historic estate homes in an Olmsted-designed neighborhood and something for everyone in Emory Village
Kirkwood: a creative, indie neighborhood with lower taxes than nearby Decatur, with a cool and hip vibe throughout Kirkwood Village
Oakhurst: front porches, sidewalks everywhere, and City of Decatur schools make it a premium location
Virginia-Highland: walkable Beltline and village life, Porchfest, and a Michelin-starred restaurant
Little Five Points: Atlanta's most colorful commercial district and the best soccer bar in the South
Poncey-Highland: a historic pub, an indie theater, and a better price point than its neighbors
A Few Neighborhoods at a Glance
The price ranges below are my rough estimates from experience, and they change with the market.
Candler Park
Homes: bungalows, Craftsmans, and Victorians from the 1920s to 1940s, about $650,000 to $2 million
Signature: Candler Park itself, with its $1 million playground, pool, and golf course, plus Candler Park Village and Page Avenue on Halloween
Getting around: sidewalks throughout, MARTA nearby, and the Freedom Park Trail to the BeltLine
Druid Hills
Homes: ranches, Victorians, and Craftsman homes on large lots, about $650,000 to $6 million
Signature: historic estate homes, Druid Hills Golf Club, Fernbank Museum, and Emory Village
Good to know: Druid Hills is split between the City of Atlanta and unincorporated DeKalb County, which can affect taxes, services, and schools
Kirkwood
Homes: about $500,000 to $1.8 million
Signature: Bessie Branham Park, Lanta Gras each February, Evergreen Butcher and Baker, and the women's sports bar Jolene Jolene
Good to know: in my experience, property taxes tend to be lower than in the neighboring City of Decatur
Oakhurst
Homes: mostly Craftsmans and bungalows, plus some new modern homes, about $650,000 to $2.5 million
Signature: the Madison Avenue Soapbox Derby, neighborhood-wide trick-or-treating, Steinbeck's Ale House, and Oakhurst Market
Good to know: Oakhurst is in the City of Decatur and the City Schools of Decatur
Virginia-Highland
Homes: apartments, historic homes, and new construction, about $650,000 to $2.5 million, with prices rising the closer you get to the village
Signature: Porchfest each May, So. Fox, Fontaine's Oyster House, Dad's, and Paolo's Gelato
Getting around: walkable to the BeltLine
Little Five Points
Homes: mostly in the bordering neighborhoods, about $600,000 to $2 million
Signature: Horizon Theatre, The Brewhouse Cafe, Sevananda Natural Foods Market, and Junkman's Daughter
Good to know: it comes alive at night, so I recommend buying at least 2 blocks away if you want quiet evenings
Poncey-Highland
Homes: about $550,000 to $1.8 million
Signature: Manuel's Tavern, the Plaza Theatre, and the Freedom Farmers Market at the Carter Center
Good to know: in my experience, it usually comes in at a better price point than neighboring Inman Park and Virginia-Highland
How to Choose the Right Intown Neighborhood
Know What You're Paying For
In my experience, five features carry the biggest premiums in intown Atlanta, and you can't add any of them later. Here are my rough estimates of each premium:
A great public school district: about 15%
Walkable to the BeltLine: about 12.5%
A basement: about 10%
Very little car traffic: about 7.5%
Within 2 blocks of a large public park: about 5%
Know Your Jurisdiction
Intown neighborhoods sit in different cities and counties. Kirkwood is in the City of Atlanta and DeKalb County. Oakhurst is in the City of Decatur. Druid Hills is split between Atlanta and unincorporated DeKalb. The jurisdiction can change your property taxes, city services, and school assignments, so always check for the specific address.
Make a Lifestyle Decision and a Spreadsheet Decision
Every house is both a lifestyle decision and a spreadsheet decision. I like to start a search intown and work outward with each client until we find the home that fits both the numbers and the way they actually want to live.
Find Your Intown Atlanta Neighborhood
Candler Park, Druid Hills, Kirkwood, Oakhurst, Virginia-Highland, Little Five Points, and Poncey-Highland each offer a different version of intown Atlanta living. The right one depends on your budget, your commute, and how you want to spend your Saturdays.
If you're thinking about buying or selling in intown Atlanta, let's talk. I've lived in these neighborhoods, and I'd love to help you find the one that fits.