Buying an Older Home in Intown Atlanta: A Builder's Checklist
Much of intown Atlanta's charm comes from its older homes. Neighborhoods like Candler Park, Inman Park, Druid Hills and Oakhurst are full of bungalows, Craftsmans, and Victorians, many built from the 1920s to the 1940s. But an older home comes with things a newer one doesn't.
I'm Alan Corey, founder of Atlanta Brokers Collective and leader of the Alan Corey Team. Before and alongside my work as an agent, I've built more than 12 new construction homes in Atlanta, flipped more than 50, and bought about a dozen homes as an investor. Here's the checklist I walk through with buyers looking at older intown homes.
The Short Answer
Don't let the age of the roof or appliances kill the right house
Get repair agreements in writing, with clear details
Look for untapped square footage
Know that basements are rare, and why
Check for creeks and flood zones before you fall in love
Know your jurisdiction
Plan for upcoming repairs, and line up good contractors
1. Don't Let the Roof Age Kill the Right House
On a tour, buyers often focus on the age of the roof or the appliances. Those details come out in the disclosures and the inspection. In my experience, they're often already priced into the house. If they aren't, you can negotiate a better price before you make an offer or after the inspection. If a house is perfect for you in every other way, an aging roof shouldn't be the hang-up.
2. Get Repair Agreements in Writing, With Details
When the inspection finds a problem, how the repair agreement is written matters as much as the repair itself. I've seen sellers agree to fix mold in a crawl space, then call the job done after wiping it with bleach. A good repair amendment spells out:
What "done" means
Who will do the work
When the work will be finished and available for inspection before closing
3. Look for Untapped Square Footage
Square footage generally only counts as living space when it's heated and cooled. I had sellers in East Atlanta with a sunroom that wasn't being counted. We added a $4,500 mini-split, which turned about 800 square feet into living space. After better marketing and smarter pricing, the home sold for $656,500, above the sellers' $650,000 goal. When you're buying, ask what's being counted, and what could be.
4. Know That Basements Are Rare
Basements are less common in Atlanta than in many other places. In my experience, they're usually found on hilly lots, where the basement sits completely or mostly above ground. If basement space matters to you, expect to pay for it. I estimate a basement adds roughly 10% to a home's value.
5. Check for Creeks and Flood Zones First
I once had clients fall in love with a house on 2 acres. They planned to build an ADU for extended family. But the lot was in a flood zone with a creek running through it, and they wouldn't have been able to build within 75 feet of the creek. On that lot, that meant they effectively couldn't build anything.
The City of Atlanta has a 75-foot riparian buffer, or 150 feet where applicable, and building inside it requires approval from the city, according to Atlanta's Department of Watershed Management. If you're planning an addition, check for streams before you make an offer.
6. Know Your Jurisdiction
Intown homes sit in different cities and counties. Oakhurst is in the City of Decatur. Kirkwood is in the City of Atlanta and DeKalb County. Druid Hills is split between Atlanta and unincorporated DeKalb. Much of Druid Hills is also part of a historic district listed on the National Register of Historic Places, according to Wikipedia. Before you plan changes, ask which city, county, and any historic rules apply to the address.
7. Plan for Upcoming Repairs
An older home will always need something. I point out repairs and maintenance items that are coming soon, flag projects that won't pay you back, and show where you can add equity. Then I connect buyers with contractors from my network who do good work at a good price.
Buy the Charm, Not the Surprises
An older intown Atlanta home can be the best purchase you ever make. Go in knowing what's priced in, what needs to be in writing, what space could be added, and what the lot and the jurisdiction will and won't allow.
If you're thinking about buying an older home in intown Atlanta, let's talk. I'll walk it with you through a builder's eyes.